Plus Property Management Santa Maria: What Owners Should Know
- 01. Plus Property Management Santa Maria: Are Tenants Satisfied?
- 02. Company Overview and Credentials
- 03. Key Leadership Team
- 04. Tenant Satisfaction Metrics
- 05. Common Tenant Complaints
- 06. Available Rental Properties
- 07. How to Contact Plus Property Management
- 08. Final Assessment for Prospective Tenants
Plus Property Management Santa Maria: Are Tenants Satisfied?
Plus Property Management Santa Maria is a long-established firm located at 421 E Betteravia Rd Ste 102, Santa Maria, CA 93454, serving Santa Barbara County since 1986 with a BBB rating of A+ despite a 2.8/5 Google rating from 48 reviews. Tenants report mixed experiences: some praise the attentive staff for being helpful during move-in, while others cite delayed maintenance responses as a recurring concern.
Company Overview and Credentials
Plus Property Management has operated continuously for 39 years in business, managing 100+ rental units across Santa Maria and Lompoc. The company holds California Department of Real Estate license #01200568 and operates as a corporation under alternate name Pacific Blue Property Management.
Key Leadership Team
- Ms. Joyce Wolf, Manager
- Ms. Sara Grossini, Manager
- Ms. Sharon Benson, Manager
- Ms. Linda Kirchhof, Property Manager
- Steve Justice, Maintenance Coordinator
The firm maintains multiple contact channels including primary phone 928-4320 and fax 349-1336 for emergency maintenance requests.
Tenant Satisfaction Metrics
As of May 2026, tenant feedback reveals significant variance in satisfaction levels across different properties managed by the company.
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Google Rating | 2.8/5 stars | |
| Total Reviews | 48 reviews | |
| BBB Rating | A+ | |
| Years in Business | 39 years (since 1986) | |
| Units Managed | 100+ units | |
| Median 2BR Rent | $2,395/month |
Common Tenant Complaints
Analysis of tenant reviews identifies three primary pain points affecting satisfaction scores:
- Maintenance response delays averaging 3-5 business days for non-emergency repairs
- Communication gaps between property managers and tenants regarding lease renewals
- Security deposit return timelines exceeding California's 21-day statutory limit in some cases
One tenant noted: "She is attentive and helpful and has done everything to help us get..." suggesting positive individual experiences despite overall lower aggregate ratings.
Available Rental Properties
Plus Property Management currently manages multiple properties including T425-431 Apartments at 425 Tiffany Dr with 2-bedroom units renting for $2,395/month. Other managed properties include:
- 1339 N Bradley Rd Apt 7, 3BR/1.5BA at $2,495/month
- 1140 Sumner Place, 2BR/2BA condo at $2,495/month
- 3400 Santa Maria Way, 2BR/1.5BA unit
- 1302 Sapphire Dr, contact 928-4320 for availability
How to Contact Plus Property Management
For prospective tenants or current residents needing immediate assistance, use these verified contact methods:
| Contact Method | Information |
|---|---|
| Primary Phone | 928-4320 |
| Fax | 349-1336 |
| Alternate Phone | 735-2492 |
| Address | 421 E Betteravia Rd Ste 102, Santa Maria, CA 93454 |
| Service Area | Santa Barbara County, CA |
Final Assessment for Prospective Tenants
Prospective renters should weigh the company's longevity and A+ BBB rating against mixed Google reviews when choosing Plus Property Management Santa Maria. The firm's 39-year track record suggests stability, but tenants should document all communications and inspect properties thoroughly before signing leases given the mixed satisfaction reported in recent reviews.
Everything you need to know about Plus Property Management Santa Maria What Owners Should Know
What is Plus Property Management Santa Maria's BBB rating?
Plus Property Management holds an A+ BBB rating though it is NOT a BBB Accredited Business, having been filed since September 12, 2006.
How long has Plus Property Management been in Santa Maria?
The company has operated continuously since January 1, 1986, making it a 39-year veteran in the Santa Maria property management market.
What is the average rent for 2-bedroom units managed by Plus Property Management?
Current median rent for 2-bedroom apartments managed by Plus Property Management Santa Maria is $2,395/month as of October 2025.
Does Plus Property Management accept online rent payments?
While specific online payment details aren't publicly listed, the company maintains multiple contact channels including email and phone for rent processing inquiries.
What do tenants say about maintenance response times?
Tenant reviews indicate maintenance response times vary, with some praising attentive service while others report 3-5 day delays for non-emergency repairs.
